Contocracy Offers the Superintelligent AI of Roko's Basilisk Without the Threat
Credit: Tesfu Assefa

Contocracy Offers the Superintelligent AI of Roko's Basilisk Without the Threat

Roko's Basilisk imagines a superintelligence that re-creates people to punish anyone who did not help build it. Contocracy pursues the same technology without the threat: people help because they want their leader, and the superintelligence brings that leader back.
Nov 22, 2026
5 min read
0.00 MPXR

Roko’s Basilisk has unsettled the internet since it first appeared on LessWrong in 2010. The thought experiment imagines a future superintelligence that re-creates people in order to punish anyone who knew it could exist and did not help build it. Its engine is fear: help, or else.

Here is the good news. Contocracy, a new kind of leadership that AI has made possible, pursues the same technology without the threat. It is permanent leadership through continuation. One chosen person leads a community for good, an AI built from a lifetime of that person’s decisions carries on their judgment after death, and the work goes on until the leader can return. People help because they want that leader, and the superintelligence their work helps bring about would re-create the leader to bring them back, not to punish anyone.

 Mindplex readers were introduced to the concept of Contocracy in a piece on aligning AI with a single person. It has also been discussed in Hypebot, Information Matters and International Affairs Forum, and InterSpace Daily has covered it. What follows is what it means for the Basilisk.

A Lab That Wants Its Founder Back

Picture Hesperus Labs, an invented open-source research collective whose thousands of contributors are working toward beneficial superintelligence, and its founder, Matteo Linnell. Contributors join because of Linnell: the problems he picks, the partners he accepts and refuses, the releases he holds back until they are safe, and the short list of things Hesperus will never build. They do not want his judgment replaced by a committee or a successor, so the collective makes him its contocrat. He holds its highest office for good. The office cannot be handed to anyone, and it passes to no heir.

Linnell sets all of this up in life. He builds a record of his decisions and his reasons, from design reviews and funding calls to licensing choices and the arguments behind them. Operators he chose build one AI stand-in from that record, and he tests it against his own past calls while he is alive, correcting it where it misreads him. He delegates lower powers freely, as any founder does. True emergencies, such as security incidents and disasters, he hands in life to established institutions, from national governments to his church.

What the Stand-In Decides

After Linnell’s death, the stand-in acts, and if he authorizes it, it can also act while he is alive but cannot be reached. It answers one kind of question: what Linnell would have wanted, where Hesperus’s mission, his religion and its technology meet. Whether to release a new model openly or hold it back, which partner fits the mission, or which line of research deserves a decade, the stand-in finds his past reasoning and rules as he would have. Everyone knows the stand-in is deciding, and every ruling is logged with the record entries it relied on.

Linnell is Catholic, and where the mission and his religion pull apart, his religion prevails. He knows the Church’s teaching can change, so if it does, the stand-in does what he would have done. Verified material, such as family photos, may be added to the record after his death, though he aims to assemble it himself. Models will improve, and the stand-in can be rebuilt on a better one, but only if the new model matches his record at least as well.

Credit: Tesfu Assefa
Credit: Tesfu Assefa

The Return, Without the Threat

At Linnell’s death, his office is held in abeyance. It remains his. He is cryopreserved at a facility such as Alcor, whose Arizona operation InvestigateTV profiled this month. Contocracy expects cryopreservation but does not require it. Unlike Contocracy, cryopreservation is built for the day instant revival works, when Linnell would return with the same authority he held.

Without a preserved body, his return would depend on re-creation by advanced AI, the very technology the Basilisk imagines. Here, Contocracy points the other way—toward a mutual win grounded in the participants’ own will, driven by reward instead of punishment. Contributors help build toward it because they want Linnell back, and the superintelligence that grows from that work re-creates him to bring him home, not to punish anyone. No one who stayed on the sidelines is threatened. The threat becomes unnecessary.

A return counts only with proof of first-person continuity, showing that the person is Linnell himself, since a likeness does not qualify. A proven return brings a full briefing on everything that happened and the power to reverse any of the stand-in’s rulings. Until then, the stand-in covers the time between.

The Hard Questions

Future contributors never chose Linnell. Everyone who joins, though, knows from the first day who holds the top office and what the stand-in decides. A record also cannot anticipate every new situation, which is why the stand-in handles what Linnell would have wanted and leaves the engineering to the people doing it.

Some questions remain open, including who can challenge the stand-in’s rulings and whether some decisions should wait for Linnell’s return. Waiting makes sense mainly when a return seems imminent. If a return never becomes verifiable, the office remains his, held in abeyance, while the stand-in carries his judgment forward.

A Better Reason to Build

The Basilisk asked people to help out of fear. Contocracy offers a better reason: a leader they want, a mission that stays on course, and a future technology that brings that leader back. If your project already wants one person’s judgment for good, call the arrangement a contocracy, call that person its contocrat, and start the record today.

Credit: Created with Claude ( Figure 1. A boomerang’s flight as a picture of contocracy’s path: a leader builds a record in life, an AI stand-in carries the leader’s judgment while the office is held in abeyance, and a superintelligence brings the leader back with the same authority.)
Credit: Created with Claude ( Figure 1. A boomerang’s flight as a picture of contocracy’s path: a leader builds a record in life, an AI stand-in carries the leader’s judgment while the office is held in abeyance, and a superintelligence brings the leader back with the same authority.)
Competing interests: I proposed the term contocracy. Funding: none.

About the Writer

More from Mindplex

Keep reading

Three more ideas worth your time.

Browse Community

Discussion

Join the discussion

Sign in to share a response with the community.

Type @ to mention someone Type / or use + to add a block Highlight text, then choose Link
Loading editor

Comments cannot be edited after posting because they become part of the reputation record. Give yours a quick review first.